Which Trading Strategy Is The Best One?

Sophia Todorova is the host of the live trading room for the London session. She has a background in teaching and psychology, and as such relishes the idea of assisting new traders on their journey to Forex trading success. Technical Analysis is her passion. The charts speak, and she listens. To Trade Live with Sophia Join Winners Edge Trading Premium Services.

In the quest to become a successful Forex trader, one of the major factors that have to be considered, is the trading strategy to adopt. While many people tend to be eclectic in their approach, there is significant potential for harm if this is done by a beginner trader who alternates between swing/ position trading, scalping, and day-trading. A trading strategy needs to be compatible with one’s personality type; Someone who is generally analytical, and needs time to decide on trades would probably not be very suited to scalping. Likewise, someone who has difficulty holding trades for extended periods could find it arduous to be a position trader. It is however, not uncommon to find experienced traders who are able to use different trading strategies without conflict.

For simplicity, I will briefly define three major types of Forex traders:

Scaper: The scalper focuses on 1-5 min timeframes, and usually aim for small pip-gain, up to about 10 pips at a time. He does this multiple times per day. Scalping requires speed in executing and exiting the trades. In scalping, the currency pairs traded are important, as the pip-spread tends to be larger on the exotics.

Day Trader: He holds positions within a trading day, with the intention of closing all positions by the end of the day. His major timeframes are the 5 minute, and 15 minute charts, and he targets between 10-50 pips at a time.

Position/Swing Trader: This trading style requires a larger risk tolerance, and as such, position sizes need to be adjusted to compensate for larger stop-losses. Pip targets for a position/swing trader are usually over 50 pips, and can be considerably more, depending on the trade setup. The 4-hour and daily timeframes are often used for trade entries.

Unarguably, it is necessary to try different trading strategies before making the decision to focus on a single one. This process usually involves a lot of ‘trial and error’, which is why I believe it is important to start one’s trading career on practice account initially, followed by a micro account. This will allow the new trader to increase trade sizes incrementally at his own pace. In this way he is able to grow according to his own learning curve without the painful experiences that can result from extensive losses.

No strategy is right or wrong, except as it related to the individual trader. Choosing the strategy that is right for you can mean the difference between a beautiful experience of learning while you develop as a trader, and one that is filled with disappointments and anxiety. Have you given any thought to this? Have you consciously considered which trading strategy might be the best one for you?

My last post was on a trade setup: http://www.winnersedgetrading.com/more-trading-opportunities-on-gbpchf/. Follow me on twitter to get updates on this trade setup.

Enjoy the rest of your weekend! :)

  • http://twitter.com/FXstorm Sophia Smith

    Hi Helder. Thank you :) Having a background in psychology does assist, but is not essential. Many persons who study psychology theoretically do not really make the connection to real life, especially in relation to themselves. Trading psychology is quite unique, and rules that should guide our behaviour as traders don't necessarily apply in real life. Thanks as always for your comments/questions :)

  • Helder

    You have indeed written a lot of very interesting articles on trading psychology as I have just found and I will be going through those as soon as possible.
    My initial request came from reading the small presention of you at the beginning of your articles, in particular your background in teaching and psychology. From an academic point of view, how did your background helped improvw your trading? If I or any other person had the time and capital to enroll in a Psychological degree, would that be something that you would recommend? Even if the objective is to only attend during the first year to catch some of the ABCs of Psychology.

    Thank you for the time you take to write and reply to all you comments.

  • http://twitter.com/FXstorm Sophia Smith

    Helder, once again you have made some very good points. Thanks for your input. I couldn't agree more about the relevance of account size. Position size is what is critical. I really do appreciate the feedback, and will be doing another article soon on trading psychology. my earliest articles on this blog focused quite a bit on this. Thanks again, and have a great day :)

  • Helder

    Well put Sophia.

    When I started trading, on a demo account, I started Scalping mainly because it was exiciting and because I believed only a large account would allow me to Swing Trade. I came to realize that this method wasn't for me simply because 1) I like to analyse medium to long-term trends and charts, 2) I tend to work and live on year by year objectives, 3) I couldn't handle the emotional turmoil caused by Scalping.

    All of these only came to me as I experienced all the 3 major types of trading presented by Sophia. I now feel confortable as a Position or Swing Trader. Experience showed me that this type of trading suits me best, and as you learn about Position Trading you you'll realize that you don't necessarily need a big account. A big account might allow you to play 4 to 6 opportunities a year, a smaller account might give you enough to play 2 or 3 opportunities a year. Again, it's not the size of your account that will dictate your rate of success. If you cannot be successful on a 50$ account you sure won't be successful on a 50,000$ account.

    As a trader your objective is not to make money, but to trade well!

    Following on Mihai's request, I would also like to ask you your opinion on trader's creating a solid Psychology background by enrolling in Psychology classes? With all the information available on the internet how productive would it be? Thank you.

    Happy trading everyone.

  • http://twitter.com/FXstorm Sophia Smith

    Thanks for the comment and feedback, mihai. Since you requested it, I'll plan an article addressing common trading terminology. I do think that is a good idea. Thank you! :)

  • mihai o.

    Great article! I would appreciate if you would come with another one explaining a bit terms like: momentumum, range and breakout strategies.
    Thank you